By Joshua Caruso, Senior Rabbi, Congregation Mishkan Or
Below is an adaption of a talk given at Church of the Resurrection-Solon on Oct. 20, 2026
Years ago, a colleague of mine spoke at a rabbinical conference. He talked about how inspirational the youth were at his synagogue in the United States. He talked about stopping in for a prayer service one day and witnessing the kids singing “Od Yavo Shalom.”
It invokes the words “Shalom” and “Salaam.” Peace. The song implores the God who makes peace in the high heavens to bring peace here on earth for us and for every inhabitant of the world.
My colleague reflected on that day, and how special it was to know that in his little corner of the world, Jewish children were singing a song about peace that included the Arabic word for peace, too. Then his tone and mood dropped. He confessed, “I sometimes wonder if there is any corner of the world where our Arab cousins, Muslim and Christian, are singing a similar song, using the Hebrew word, ‘Shalom.'” When I heard him tell that story, I immediately wondered if our Muslim and Christian brethren know that we sing such a song at all.
I begin with this story to share that this is a song that our community at Congregation Mishkan Or sings in its religious school, on retreats and during services. In fact, the liturgy of Jewish worship is filled with words of Shalom – the rabbis mandated it so. In fact, “Shalom” is in the Jewish DNA; it is in the fiber of every Jewish soul.
And…along with Shalom, the Jewish DNA also includes aspects of trauma, generational pain, and collective hurts that go back thousands of years, dating to the time of our slavery in ancient Egypt. Importantly, there is one more thing that Jews are equipped with: resilience.
The deep wound of the Holocaust, where six million Jews were marched to their death, was reopened by the events of October 7, 2023. It is the prism through which every Jew views the world, particularly Israelis, who are still stuck in that trauma while knowing that our enemies continue to plot new ways to eliminate us.
Father Dragga asked me to convey what outsiders should understand about Jewish life in Israel. So let me begin by sharing that the Jewish relationship with the State of Israel is built on a foundation of pain, resilience and strength born from being outsiders ourselves.
***
The large majority of diaspora Jews view Israel as our eternal homeland, first settled by the biblical Abraham almost 4,000 years ago. We Jews have survived the vicissitudes of world history as a small tribal group that has largely lived in exile. Our origins can be traced back to the Fertile Crescent – think Persia (now Iran), Babylonia (now Iraq), and Judea (now Israel).
We have learned to adapt throughout our history as a small tribe without power, chiefly living under the sovereignty of other nations and treated like second-class citizens. We have built two temples in Jerusalem, and were exiled twice, first by the Babylonian Empire in 586 BCE and later by the Roman Empire in 70 CE.
Ever since the second temple was destroyed nearly 2,000 years ago, Jews have lived in foreign lands. We have been victimized as a result of the Crusades, expelled and executed by the Spanish during the Inquisition, subjected to attacks in eastern Europe (the Pale of Settlement) from the 17th through the 19th centuries, and faced the worst collective tragedy in our people’s history when six million Jews were exterminated by the Nazi regime. These are just the highlights (or lowlights!).
Time and again, Jews tried to settle in lands controlled by other nations: Persia, Babylonia, Yemen, Morocco, Tunisia, Spain, Portugal, Russia, Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Ukraine, Moldova, Belarus, Holland, Germany, Austria, France…the list goes on and on. In each place, Jews sought to embrace pride of nationhood, but every time we tried to acculturate or assimilate, we became the lightning rod for national discontent about something that had gone wrong for them (that had nothing to do with us).
We were – and still are – the proverbial scapegoat.
It was in the wake of these repeated refusals to become part of the fabric of the cultures and societies to which we contributed that modern Zionism was born. Zionism is defined as the right of every Jew in the world to have a haven, to live under self-determination, in our ancestral land – Israel.
The Torah, which are the first five books of scripture, give a detailed history of that quest. It started with Abraham and Sarah, passed down to Jacob, and then to Moses, and succeeded by Joshua, who entered that land with the tribal families. That was more than 3,000 years ago.
Israel, known by many names, and held by many dynasties, was a political football for years. Since the destruction of the second temple, Jerusalem and its environs have been controlled by the Romans, the Byzantines, Islamic Caliphates, the Crusaders, the Ayyubids, the Mamluks, the Ottoman Turks and the British.
Throughout those years, the land has been inhabited by a myriad of pilgrims and religious types who made their home in the land. Arabs and Jews can both count multiple generations of inhabitants in the land. The ancestral land of the Jews, that goes back to the time of Abraham and Joshua, King Saul, David and Solomon, Samuel, Elijah, Amos, Isaiah and Jeremiah, and even in exile we wept by the rivers of Babylon, praying to return, in great numbers, to that land under our own sovereignty.
Eventually, in the late 19th century, my people experienced enough degradation and disappointment and gave birth to a modern iteration of an ancient idea, Zionism. “Zionism” emerged from the biblical word, “Tzion,” which is one of Israel’s core designations (think of the line from Psalms, “By the waters of Babylon we lay down and wept for thee Zion”).
Zionism has existed for thousands of years.
***
The modern Zionist movement began in the late 1800s, founded by Theodore Herzl. Herzl, a secular Jew, who knew his history, and in his own day witnessed antisemitism in his birthplace of Austria, and later in France. In 1897, at the First Zionist Congress, Jewish leaders from across the world gathered to address the increasingly dangerous antisemitism that was moving from latency to overt hate crimes. The proposal from Herzl was to create a nation-state where Jews could practice self-determination at a time when every nation they tried to inhabit rejected them. Herzl famously said, “If you will it, it is not a dream”.
The dream for a homeland where Jews could be free started to feel real.
Still, some fled to America (a huge influx of eastern European Jews) between the years of 1880 and 1920. Others moved through waves of immigration to Palestine. Those desperate Jews, indigent and battered from state-sponsored pogroms, found a malaria-ridden land and turned the desert into a blooming landscape. Religious and secular Jews found deep meaning in the land of their ancestors. And even for the non-believers, the land had spiritual power. It was a land of redemption, nearly two thousand years in the making!
During those waves of immigration, the Turks and the Brits were in charge, but the land was inhabited by both Arabs and Jews. During the first half of the 20th century there were battles and there were slayings, but there were also friendships between Jewish and Arab cousins, descendants of Abraham or Ibrahim.
The name, Palestine, known today as Israel, comes from ancient roots. The name was first connected to the Philistines of the ancient near east, then turned into Palestina by the Romans, and eventually deemed “Palestine” by the Ottomans and the British. “Palestinians”, was a designation given to any inhabitant living in the land of Palestine. Jews were called Palestinians. Arabs were called Palestinians, too.
As fellow Palestinians, Jews and Arabs had their differences, but they also shared friendships – villages abutted one next to another. They shared their bounty. They shared the land. They, at times, lived in great harmony. Hostilities persisted, but there was hope that Shalom/Salaam was a worthwhile aspiration. As Jewish and Arab factions began to harden, the British saw that tensions were growing. The world saw these tensions growing.
Meanwhile, Jewish refugees in Europe, who were bound for slaughter, were freed – many of them orphaned. Jews were relegated to displaced persons camps. With nowhere else to go, they headed to Palestine…with a hope for refuge and a safe haven from those who wished us dead.
On November 29, 1947, the United Nations passed the UN Partition Plan for Palestine, which would effectively end the British Mandate there (this was the first time the international community recognized a Jewish State). It was the first two-state solution. The plan partitioned the land into two states: one Jewish and one Arab. The Jewish Agency, a representative arm for the Jewish people accepted the plan, even amid reservations. Arab leaders in Palestine and in the surrounding Arab states rejected the plan outright. As a result of the failure to pass the plan, violence amongst Arabs and Jews intensified, and the 1948 Arab-Israeli War commenced.
Further wars dotted the oncoming years in 1956 (Suez Crisis), 1967, 1973 (Yom Kippur War), 1978 (Lebanon), two Intifadas, a second Lebanon war, and Gaza wars leading up to the war with Hamas following October 7 – and it’s still going on. There have been many lives lost, generational pain, and failed attempts at peace…again and again and again.
Throughout the years, Israelis have been living with a siege mentality, as enemy factions named Hamas, Hizbollah, and Islamic Jihad (sponsored by Iran) have dispatched suicide bombers, rockets, and missiles to terrorize Israelis repeatedly. These tactics have hardened Israelis and have made them increasingly skeptical of a two-state solution. In fact, if you ask a random Israeli citizen today if they believe in a shared path with their Arab cousins, they will tell you, “That ship has sailed”. You see, it’s not that Israelis don’t want peace. It’s because humans have a threshold for heartbreak for pain and loss, and sadly, most Israeli Jews have given up hope.
This is what makes singing about Shalom and Salaam today in a synagogue setting even more tragic – we still aspire for peace, but the path there is no longer clear.
And October 7, 2023, only hardened that position.
On that fateful day, Hamas killed 1200 civilians and soldiers and took more than 250 individuals into captivity into Gaza. The brutality of Hamas brought every Jew to his knees. Babies were beheaded, women were raped, and senior citizens were terrorized and murdered in front of their loved ones.
Three years ago, on the sabbath following October 7th, I shared the following words with my congregation:
I am maddened, that our beloved Israel was outsmarted by terrorists who killed our people knowing full well that we would retaliate, and would surely kill civilians, women and children placed helpless in the line of fire…all according to their plan. They have used their people as pawns to rid the land of Jews.
I am furious as the death toll rises, and soon the tide of pro-Israel sentiment will turn against us, and we will once again be demonized.
I am angry that Palestinian supporters around the world are expressing joy following the desecration of our people, as if Israel’s intractable trials with the Palestinian people should ever justify mass killings, rape, beheadings, and hostage-taking of innocents.
I am livid that somehow the Palestinian struggle for rights has been taken up as the civil rights cause of our world by those who have no nuanced understanding of history, with Israel always to blame. In lieu of legitimate critique of Israel’s governmental policies, we are prey to wholesale anti-Semitic rhetoric cloaked in progressivism.
I am mad that the world, including Arab nations, refuse to care one damn about the most vulnerable in Gaza. Where are the emergency transports to carry children, parents, and the infirm to find new homes for them? Where is Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria? How is Iran, Hamas’ patron, caring for the infirm, the elderly and the innocent victims of everyday Gazans?
***
Few know what it is like to live with the trauma of October 7. May you never know it yourselves. Pain, anger and grief rule life in the Holy Land, and still Israelis are resilient. There has been some modicum of healing, and the greatest strength Israel has is the solidarity among its people.
The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) is the foundation of Israeli society. The overwhelming majority of soldiers (like my nephew, Chanina) are committed to the security of the country and their people. Parents send their kids to the army not knowing if they will ever return. Every day they wade into harm’s way to protect their people. They defend the borders that have been breached by terrorist organizations largely funded by Iran.
Here is what a politically moderate Israeli friend of mine wrote to me a few months ago (he has two of his three daughters currently serving in the IDF):
Trying to find the words to describe these events we are going through, both for myself and for when I am asked to explain it to others…we have to hold in our hearts both the fact that we know with every fiber of our being that Trump and Netanyahu are terrible for each of our counties, are the collective worst that our countries can produce, cannot ever reflect who we are as a people and absolutely do not represent what our values and morals are as Jews, Israelis and Americans- and….that this is war of no other choice and that while there may be those who speak of it as an unprovoked invasion, Israel has been on the receiving end of 47 years of murderous aggression with the sole purpose of death and destruction to Israel, Israelis and Jews everywhere. This was never acceptable and with the continued delusional yet very capable efforts of Iran to kill my family, neighbors, friends and strangers alike, there was no choice but to end this once and for all because we are done living with a guillotine over our heads. At the same time we live within the reality of cognitive dissonance between the pain, anger, humiliation of an IDF that failed in the grandest of ways on October 7 because of our hubris, tunnel vision, blind spots, lack of imagination, condescending attitude towards our enemies and…the knowledge that every moment since then has seen rise of a people and a military unwavering, courageous, creative, capable, fighting for its people, its family, its comrades and its right to walk tall again, to live again, representing all of the ideals we know we have as we stand shoulder to shoulder on our frontlines declaring with all of our heart, soul and might that we not only have a right to live but a right to thrive and we stand awe struck at the incredible men and women who have taken the fight to the enemy- in the south, in the north and in the east.
***
There is a famous quote by Israel’s former prime minister, Gold Meir:
“We can forgive the Arabs for killing our children. We cannot forgive them for forcing us to kill their children. We will only have peace with the Arabs when they love their children more than they hate us.”
The war with Hamas has been brutal. Before Israeli Jews had a chance to mourn their dead, to even bury them, the world conveniently forgot about them, and in Israel’s retaliation turned against Israel.
Israel’s reprisals against Hamas have invited legitimate questions about the magnitude of the response and the number of casualties reported – and some of that criticism is appropriate. I, too, have asked those questions. My community asks those questions – sometimes privately and sometimes publicly. No Jew, who stands for the values taught in our scripture and rabbinic literature, celebrates when innocents die in the trials of war. We know there was tremendous collateral damage as Hamas operatives shrewdly fired on Israel from inside hospitals, mosques, and schools.
If we are to be true seekers of peace, we must reflect on the preponderance of death and destruction that leveled Gaza. As true seekers of Shalom, we must consider what has been wrought, and how, if ever, we can find our way back to a shared path. As true seekers of peace, we must own the reality of the generational pain felt by Jews and Palestinians. As seekers of peace, the Israeli government must address the shameful settler violence occurring in the West Bank right now. This is not Jewish behavior.
And…and…the only way all of us can heal is if Israel’s pain, grief and loss is acknowledged and honored by the world and not set aside as a lesser suffering. Sadly, there is plenty of suffering in the world and we must regard one family’s loss as grave as another’s.
There is some good news. Mishkan Or is partnering with Givat Haviva, an institute that seeks a shared path with Arab Israeli citizens (about 20% of Israeli citizens are Arab Muslims or Christians). They have a school where a third of the students are Israeli Jews, a third are Israeli Arabs, and a third enroll from outside of Israel. There is an organization named, “Standing Together,” that joins Israelis and Arabs in fighting for a shared path. And right here in Northeast Ohio, Mishkan Or is a founding organization of the Interfaith Group Against Hate, which counts Jewish, Christian, and Muslim congregations as its members. We refuse to allow hate to win.
I know that my temple will continue to sing songs of peace, and I pray that our Muslim and Christian Arab cousins will do so, too. It is the only way forward.